S DM Copyright Act

LEGAL



DM Copyright Act

Liability under the original Copyright Act left Internet Service Providers (ISPs), i.e. Yahoo, AOL, and electronic Bulletin Board Services (BBS) wide open for copyright infringement lawsuits. Any time a user took a copyrighted work, threw it on a BBS, via his or her ISP connection, for a recipient to read, everyone (ISP, BBS, sender and receiver) could have been liable under one form of liability or another.

The reason for this is that liability under the Copyright Act is absolute. That means, ``Sorry it was an accident" or ``I didn't even know they were doing it" or even ``I didn't know it was a copyrighted work" doesn't get you off. Even a third party (ISP) who is not directly involved in violating the copyright holder's rights can be found liable. This is called vicarious liability. It is imposed upon an entity or individual who has the capacity to dictate the infringing behavior, and has a direct commercial benefit in exploiting the infringement.

If vicarious infringement does not get you, then contributory infringement will. This is when a person or entity consciously encourages, causes, or materially contributes to the infringing conduct of another. From our previous example this would be the BBS supplying the forum for direct infringers to post the copyrighted work.

In order to give the ISPs a chance, Congress enacted another amendment to the Copyright Act. This amendment was called the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). See 17 U.S.C. § 512. Under the DCMA, service providers are given a ``safe harbor" provided they do the following: Furthermore, a service provider is not liable for copyright infringement when it is performing the following roles: If you are going to operate a BBS your life did get simpler with the enactment of the DCMA, however you are far from the clear.